| THE
800 MILLION DOLLAR PILL
John Carey of BUSINESS WEEK (4/19/2004:24) reviews a new book about big
pharma.
It is the 800 MILLION DOLLAR PILL: THE TRUTH BEHIND THE COST OF NEW DRUGS,
by Merrill Goozner, University of California Press, and 297pp.
What Goozner suggests pretty much sets the stage for the debate on cost
of pharmaceuticals? WELLMARK, BLUE CROSS/BLUESHIELD bulletin (M-2338*3/03)
tells members that the high cost of drugs is due to following:
1. We are getting older.
2. Drug companies are spending more money on advertising.
3. Our diseases are being treated with more drugs.
4. Receiving care as an outpatient means drugs are being covered under
a pharmacy plan instead of a medical plan.
5. We are better following doctors orders for taking drugs because dosages
are more convenient, drugs have fewer side effects and we have become
savvier drug consumers.
Goozner, former chief economics writer for the CHICAGO TRIBUNE suggest
that
Big pharmacy is partially correct in their statements and the list indicated
above... However, he notes that 30 billion dollars was spent on drugs
that are mild versions of the same old drugs dressed in new persona.
Many drugs are created by government and paid by tax payers, but pharmaceutical
houses charge immodest prices for these medicines. He also provides supporting
data that drug industries do not require 800 million dollars to develop
a new drug. That R& D budgets are geared to profitable but not greatly
improved drugs. Much of the R&D spending is not aimed at medical advances.
On the other hand, many other industries are doing the same thing to
maximize profits.
There is an ongoing conflict of doing well financially and doing what
is best for medicine.
Perhaps the answer is pricing structure. With the advent of more free
trade, drug companies must compete with open borders. U.S. Senator Charles
Grassley (R) of Iowa wants Canadian distributors to be able to compete
in drug distribution with U.S. distributors. The outcome may be reduction
in prices.
Free trade also means that other countries may compete for the large
American market too, driving prices downward. Generics may also help in
price reduction.
Wellmark, Blue Cross/Blue Shield also note that from 1996 to 2001, pharmaceuticals
have doubled their advertising. Some one has to pay for that.
|