| Ravitch,
D. (2003) THE LANGUAGE POLICE New York: Alfred Knopf, 255 pages.
Textbook wars are intense and in the great demise of common culture, red-blue struggles continue in schools. You either write a book for Evangelicals or Postmodern. If you try to bridge the gap, the best way is to keeping screening every word that is said and how it is said. Key facts may have to be rescinded or reordered to please all groups. In the end, you get splashy mush. Authors are attacked on the right by Evangelicals generally located on school boards and in book selection committees. The pressure on the left comes from the culture among writers and think tanks. Thus, the middle ground is hard to come by. So, book companies know that a book will only sell when the language is so completely devoid of meaning except to convey an exact “fact” followed by euphemisms. Ravitich indicates that books can become more interesting and colorful as well as meaningful when the teacher chooses the book. Both history and English literature books are essentially flat in content followed by study guides and numerous study assists on the print pages. Textbook companies do not want to go out of business and thus new books are flavorless and boring. The cautious writing is also helpful because the teachers are not likely to have a background in those fields. A teacher’s guide is also sent so that deskilling is involved. Therefore, nearly anyone with a bachelor’s degree can teach the courses and not know a lot about the subject. If a teacher chooses a book, then they pay the consequences or reap the benefits of an exciting text. They can always change. This is the procedure in college. K-12 textbooks are many times chosen at the state level. Thus if you
can sell your book in Texas and California, you have a best seller.
|
| Home | Essays | Small Talk | Books | About Joel Snell | Publications | Links |